UNION OF INDIA vs MAJ GEN MANOMOY GANGULY VSM

The Supreme Court upheld the Armed Forces Tribunal's decision to quash the Review Special Promotion Board's proceedings regarding the respondent's promotion to Lieutenant General, citing errors in the allotment of board marks. The Court emphasized the importance of adhering to the Promotion Policy dated 14th January, 2004, and the necessity for a fresh Review SPB to consider the respondent's improved ACR profile. The judgment reinforces the principle that promotions must be based on fair and accurate assessments as per established criteria.