Pratap Singh vs State Of U.P.& Anr

The Supreme Court addressed the appeal of a judicial officer who was reverted to a lower position after not being promoted to the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service, citing Rule 22(3) of the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975. The Court held that the remarks made in the officer's annual confidential report (ACR) were unjustified and lacked proper basis, emphasizing the need for fair evaluation in promotion matters. The Court ultimately ruled in favor of the appellant, reinstating him to his promoted position.