Niyam v2 is live — start for just ₹100 — 200 credits to try

september 2010

Supreme Court of India · 2010-09-07

Mamtaj Bi Bapusab Nadaf & Ors vs United India Insurance Co. & Ors

Citation / case number
2010 AIR SCW 5872
Court
Supreme Court of India
Petitioner
Mamtaj Bi Bapusab Nadaf & Ors
Respondent
United India Insurance Co. & Ors
Author
Dalveer Bhandari
Bench
Mukundakam Sharma, Dalveer Bhandari

Judgment text excerpt

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court's decision that the Insurance Company was not liable for compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act, as the deaths of the workmen were not directly connected to the insured vehicle. The Court emphasized that mere transportation of maize by the vehicle did not establish proximate cause for the deaths, which resulted from asphyxia in a grocery pit. The Court affirmed the High Court's ruling allowing the appellants to recover compensation from the employer instead.

Mamtaj Bi Bapusab Nadaf & Ors vs United India Insurance Co. & Ors · Niyam