UNION OF INDIA vs KALI DASS BATISH

The Supreme Court examined the scope of judicial review concerning appointments to the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) under the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, specifically Sections 4 and 14. The Court held that while the appointment process involves consultation with the Chief Justice of India, the judicial review is limited to ensuring adherence to the prescribed qualifications and procedures, without delving into the merits of individual candidates. The appeals were decided in accordance with these principles, affirming the validity of the selection process.