U O I vs SAMAR SINGH

The Supreme Court upheld the Central Administrative Tribunal's decision that the omission of the respondent's name from the panel for Secretary to the Government of India was arbitrary and unsustainable. The Court emphasized the need for proper consideration of the respondent's case in light of the Central Staffing Scheme, particularly paragraph 14, which outlines the selection process for such appointments. The Court directed the appellants to reassess the respondent's suitability for empanelment and appointment based on relevant criteria and materials, ensuring adherence to established guidelines.