STATE OF M.P. vs GANEKAR MOTGHARE

The Supreme Court held that the participation of the Head of the Department in the Screening Committee did not vitiate its recommendation for compulsory retirement under Rule 56 of the Fundamental Rules. The Court emphasized that the purpose of these rules is to maintain administrative efficiency by removing underperforming employees. The appeal was allowed, reinstating the State Government's order, and it was clarified that the respondent's pension should not be reduced despite the earlier High Court ruling.