HARI SINGH MANN vs THE STATE OF PUNJAB & ORS.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal regarding the termination of a probationary officer's service, holding that the order was not in violation of Rule 9 of the Punjab Civil Service (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1952. The Court established that the termination was based on the appellant's unsatisfactory record, which did not constitute a stigma or punishment under the rules. The Court clarified that fitness for the job is a critical factor for confirmation and that the appellant could not be considered confirmed before the probation period expired.