Niyam v2 is live — start for just ₹100 — 200 credits to try

october 1961

Supreme Court of India · 1961-10-31

RAMSARAN DAS AND BROS. vs COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, CALACUTTAAND OTHERS

Citation / case number
SC 1960/167
Court
Supreme Court of India
Petitioner
RAMSARAN DAS AND BROS.
Respondent
COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, CALACUTTAAND OTHERS
Author
SINHA, BHUVNESHWAR P.(),KAPURL.,HIDAYATULLAH, M.,SHAHC.,MUDHOLKARR.
Bench
SINHA, BHUVNESHWAR P.(CJ),KAPUR, J.L.,HIDAYATULLAH, M.,SHAH, J.C.,MUDHOLKAR, J.R.

Judgment text excerpt

The Supreme Court held that an assessee must exhaust statutory remedies before appealing directly under Article 136 of the Constitution of India against an assessment order. The Court emphasized that without final determination of facts by the assessing authority or invocation of High Court jurisdiction, the appeal is incompetent. This ruling aligns with precedents such as Mahadayal Premchandras v. Commercial Tax Officer Calcutta and The State of Bombay v. M/s. Ratilal Vedilal, reinforcing the principle that direct appeals to the Supreme Court are not ordinarily permissible in tax matters.

RAMSARAN DAS AND BROS. vs COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, CALACUTTAAND OTHERS · Niyam