HASMUKH SHAH vs BHANUMALI BEN S. SHAH AND ORS

Judgment text excerpt

Digitally signed by WP.3721.2004 (J) C3.doc ANANT ANANT KRISHNA KRISHNA NAIK IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAIK Date: 2026.06.08 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION 19:20:15 +0530 WRIT PETITION NO. 3721 OF 2004 1. Shivlal Vithaldas Shah (since deceased) through legal heirs and representatives 1A. Smt. Bhanumali Shivalal Shah Wife, age/69 1B. Shri. Mukesh Shivlal Shah Son, age/45 1C. Smt. Bhavna Nilesh Boldra Daughter, age/42 1D. Smt. Rupa Jhon Alphonso Daughter, age/35 1E. Shri.Viren Shivlal Shah Son, Age/33 R/o at Navghar, Manikpur, Vasai District : Thane. 2. Ambika Sales Corporation through its Proprietor Shivlal Vithaldas Shah No.1 abovenamed residing at Navghar/Manikpur Vasai, District: Thane ... Petitioners Versus Hasmukh Mansukhlal Shah Adult, occupation: Business Residing at ...Respondent/ ‘Satyam’ Ambadi road, Vasai, Distrist : Thane. Original Plaintiff akn 1 WP.3721.2004 (J) C3.doc WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 558 OF 2019 Hasmukh Shah ...Applicant/ Orig. Respondent/Plaintiff Versus Bhanumali Ben S. Shah & Ors. ...Respondents. WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 559 OF 2019 Hasmukh Mansukhlal Shah ...Applicant Versus Shivlal Vithaldas Shah (since deceased) through Lrs 1A Smt. Bhanumali Shivala Shah & Ors. ...Respondents. **** Mr. Prasad S. Dani, Senior Advocate a/w. Adv. Jayesh M. Joshi for the Petitioners. Mr. Prasad K. Dhakephalkar, Senior Advocate (through VC) a/w. Adv. Pranav Sampat, Adv. Yash Kataria i/b. Khaitan & Co. for the Respondent. **** CORAM : M. M. SATHAYE, J. RESERVED ON : 13th JANUARY 2026 PRONOUNCED ON : 8th JUNE, 2026 JUDGMENT : 1. This Petition is filed by tenants against the Respondent/landlord under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India challenging the judgment and decree dated 05.03.2004 passed in Civil Appeal No. 96 of 1999 by Additi