ROHIT RAMESH PALVE and ANR. vs TULA SHANKAR PALAVE and ANR.

Judgment text excerpt

2025:BHC-AS:9424 26 SA-289-2020.doc IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION SECOND APPEAL NO. 289 OF 2020 1. Rohit Ramesh Palve ] Age 28, Occu - Agriculturist ] 2. Rekha Ramesh Palve ] Age 49, Occu – Agriculturist ] Both r/o Samart Ashok Nagar, ] Dasak, District - Nashik ] ...Appellants Versus 1. Tula Shankar Palave ] Age : 66 ] R/o. I.S.P. Staff Quarters, F. No. 46, Behind ] ISP School, Nashik-Road. ] 2. Punjabai Sadu Tapase ] Age : 46, Occu : Household, ] R/o Dahegaon, Tal and Dist. Nashik. ] 3. Laxmibai Dhanaji Palave, ] Age : 45, Occu : Household ] 4. Ranjendra Dhanaji Palave ] Age : 45, Occu: ] 5. Shobhabai Balu Pawar ] Age : 49 ] 6. Sunita Dhanaji Palave ] Age : ] 7. Manisha Dhanaji Palave ] Age : ] Resp. No. 3 to 7 R/o Wadala, Tal. And Dist. ] Nashik ] 8. Kisan Waman Borade, ] Age : ] r/o Pimpalgaon Khamb, Tal and Dist. Nashik ] 9. Shantaram Deoram @ Jayaram Navale ] R/o C/o Kisan Waman Borade, Bhavani Nagar, ] At Post Pimpalgaon khamb, (Via Ambad), Tal. ] And Dist Nashik. ] Sairaj 1 of 6 26 SA-289-2020.doc 10. Suman Bapu Mate ] Age : 76 ] R/o Pimpalgaon Khamb, ] Tal and Dist Nashik. ] 11. Shobha Nandu Jadhav, ] Age : 74 ] R/o. Aadgaon, Tal and Dist Nashik. ] 12. Baby Ashok Porje, ] Age : 71, ] R/o Pegalwadi, Tal. Trimbakeshwar, ] Dist. Nashik. ] 13. Sindhubai Sukhdeo Suryavanshi, ] Age : 69 ] R/o Saptashrungi Mata Nagar, At ] Nandurgaon, Post Madsangavi, Tal and Dist ] Nashik. ] 14. Murlidhar Keru Sonawane ] Age : Major, ] 15. Chandrabhaga Keru Sonawane, ] Age : Major ] R/o Pimpalgaon Khamb, Tal and Dist. Nashik ] ...Respondents —————— Mr. Nikhil M. Pujari for Appellants. Mr. Amey Deshpande, Ms. Niyati Sontakke for Respondent Nos. 5 to 7. —————— Coram : Sharmila U. Deshmukh, J. Date : 6th November, 2025. Judgment : 1. The Second Ap