# SHIVLAL VITHALDAS SHAH AND ANR. vs HASMUKH MANSUKHLAL SHAH

Court: Bombay High Court
Date: 2026-06-08
Citation: WP/3721/2004
Petitioner: SHIVLAL VITHALDAS SHAH AND ANR.
Respondent: HASMUKH MANSUKHLAL SHAH

[Official PDF on Bombay High Court website](https://bombayhighcourt.gov.in/bhc/file/download/eyJpdiI6IkNiUW1IWUZpTW5mc05kQnNjWlNMcXc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibkpMSndrcVF5RHk1YWJJYjUreTc3WE82c1BVMnFZWFVpckZXRVJDM2JkTWxCZWo2VXVpMWZGT2tHaDdtalZtSmdUdzRtQ0xPOWlWbCs2bHJ5UTh4ZGc9PSIsIm1hYyI6ImNjNmMxN2Q0NTU4YmUwODc0YjRkYjQ3OWVhYTE0ODE0ZWMxNzEzOTA5ZTVmZGIzZmQ1YTAzMzRlOTBlZTVkYTciLCJ0YWciOiIifQ==?expires=1782737383&signature=c5eec68fb702ce977516185864040e00678e5d9dd2a9e8c9ae003d599f76d817)

## Judgment text (excerpt)

1. Shivlal Vithaldas Shah (since deceased) through legal heirs and representatives 1A. Smt. Bhanumali Shivalal Shah Wife, age/69 1B. Shri. Mukesh Shivlal Shah Son, age/45 1C. Smt. Bhavna Nilesh Boldra Daughter, age/42 1D. Smt. Rupa Jhon Alphonso Daughter, age/35 1E. Shri.Viren Shivlal Shah Son, Age/33 R/o at Navghar, Manikpur, Vasai District : Thane. 2. Ambika Sales Corporation through its Proprietor Shivlal Vithaldas Shah No.1 abovenamed residing at Navghar/Manikpur Vasai, District: Thane ... Petitioners Versus Hasmukh Mansukhlal Shah Adult, occupation: Business Residing at ...Respondent/ ‘Satyam’ Ambadi road, Vasai, Distrist : Thane. Original Plaintiff akn 1 WP.3721.2004 (J) C3.doc WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 558 OF 2019 Hasmukh Shah ...Applicant/ Orig. Respondent/Plaintiff Versus Bhanumali Ben S. Shah & Ors. ...Respondents. WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 559 OF 2019 Hasmukh Mansukhlal Shah ...Applicant Versus Shivlal Vithaldas Shah (since deceased) through Lrs 1A Smt. Bhanumali Shivala Shah & Ors. ...Respondents. **** Mr. Prasad S. Dani, Senior Advocate a/w. Adv. Jayesh M. Joshi for the Petitioners. Mr. Prasad K. Dhakephalkar, Senior Advocate (through VC) a/w. Adv. Pranav Sampat, Adv

https://niyam.ai/judgements/high-court/2026/june/shivlal-vithaldas-shah-and-anr-vs-hasmukh-mansukhlal-shah