# SMT.BERTHA CARVALHO andANR vs 1.SHRI BALDWIN JOSEPH FRANCIS D,SOUZA and ANR.

Court: Bombay High Court
Date: 2025-12-09
Citation: WP/3144/1993
Petitioner: SMT.BERTHA CARVALHO andANR
Respondent: 1.SHRI BALDWIN JOSEPH FRANCIS D,SOUZA and ANR.

[Official PDF on Bombay High Court website](https://bombayhighcourt.gov.in/bhc/file/download/eyJpdiI6IlVRenE0UlF6V3l5SHV6TTNmYnJNQVE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiMFE5aENIQjBvV1ZuMVlpRTRhVEJTTUxrOTI1Y2lpejRkUXZiRktNZC9oTVdMV1BpTmZDZmZlOTZqTVJsUFNWOEdBVzBTZFBiMFhwcDBZVVp0L3BJTmc9PSIsIm1hYyI6ImU2ZmEyMjk1NmY0MWViNzY3OWNmZDljNGRiZmYyNzFlYTk2OTIzMDU3NTkzZjlkN2UzYWE5MjZlZGUyNTAzMzIiLCJ0YWciOiIifQ==?expires=1782773251&signature=83e96d7dc82852290e1ad815e81f70a4e1f1b90df07eeaac5612c96d768fe628)

## Judgment text (excerpt)

1. Smt. Bertha Carvalho (since deceased) Through Legal heirs 1(a) Mr. Alban Couto Indian Inhabitant, Residing at 1037, Sonatem, Carona Aldona, Bardez, Goa 403523 1(b) Mr. Anil Pinto Indian Inhabitant residing at 67, Denisandra, Gokhale Road, North, Dadar, Mumbaí 400028 2. Shri Ross Carvalho (since deceased) Through Legal heirs 2(a) Emil Josef Carvalho Age 56 years, Occupation: Voluntary Consultant residing at Alvorada Flat 2A, Off St Roque Road, behind Mehboob Studio, Bandra (West) Mumbai 400050 2(b) Yvan Ross Carvalho Age 51 years, Occupation:Business, residing at Alvorada Flat 3, Off St Roque Road, behind Mehboob Studio, Bandra (West) Mumbai 400050 2(c) Yohann Francis Carvalho Age 45 years, Occupation: Banker, residing at C1402, Ashok Gardens, Tokershi Jivraj Road, Sewri (West), Mumbai 4000015 all in their capacities as the Executors and Trustees named in the akn 1/26 WP.3144.1993 (J) C3.odt Will dated 24th February, 2012 of the deceased Plaintiff No. 2 ...Petitioners (Orig. Plaintiffs) VERSUS 1. Shri Baldwin Joseph Francis D' Souza (Since deceased) Through legal heirs. 1(a) Bernadette Rita Mary D’Souza Age 87 years, Occupation: Not Known, residing at 1A Alvorada, Off St Roque Ro

https://niyam.ai/judgements/high-court/2025/december/smt-bertha-carvalho-andanr-vs-1-shri-baldwin-joseph-francis-d-souza-and-anr